May
Retrospective Sunday #2: Why Not Gastric Bypass?
Posted in retrospective | No Comments »Once I decided I wanted to lose weight, the next question was, HOW? I consider myself a reasonably intelligent person, and fairly well-read on all things diet. One could even consider me a diet expert, given the number of times I’d been on one.
Granted, the peanut butter diet I tried when I was twelve was not terribly effective. (The idea: One big spoon of peanut butter a day. I was supposed to just lick at it all day long). Fat camp was not fun, and they don’t make fat camps for 40 year olds anyway (do they?). Hiding food from me or bribing me to lose weight didn’t work out, as my parents discovered.
And as I had read, diets don’t work. Even the super supervised diets, people only lost a few pounds. People tended to gain it all back, and then some, after a year or two.
So, I started to think about gastric bypass. It seemed the easier way out (though I hadn’t at the time read about the horror stories) I had gotten a small inheritence from my grandmother, who was obsessed with weight her entire life, and it seemed like something she would more than approve of.
So why didn’t I? Five reasons:
- I didn’t consider my weight to be life threatening. Sure, according to the charts, I was “morbidly obese” (don’t you love that term? It’s like I could expire at any moment!). But I didn’t have diabetes, high blood pressure, heart issues.
- Surgery is life threatening. Even the most benign surgery could have a “negative outcome”. I had too much to live for–a husband and two kids who needed me.
- Do I really need to chop up my body to stop eating? Eating is ultimately something I could control. I could, if I really tried, stop pushing food into my mouth.
- What would the long term effects be? I hadn’t done the research, to be honest, but malabsorbtion of food seemed a real possibility. What if it came undone?
- Even with surgery, I’d still have to eat less. Surgery might make it easier to do so, or it might just make it more inconvenient. If I didn’t learn life skills, I could see myself as one of those people drinking milkshakes or eating frosting out of the can to get my fix.
It’s not that I had ruled out gastric bypass or banding or another surgical option; it just didn’t seem like the most sensible Plan A. For me, it would be an attempt at a shortcut.
Now, I don’t doubt that weight loss surgery is the right route for many people. I know those who have WLS work plenty hard, so no flames, please! But most try other solutions first. For me, it was just wishing for something magical that didn’t require any work, and I don’t believe in magic.
Next week: How I chose Weight Watchers

The faster they lose, the faster they gain. I gained 4.2 lbs this week, and I definitely didn’t have 4.2 lbs of fun and food, believe me.